Review: Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 Hyper-Wide Heliar (Sony E-Mount)

Review: Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 Hyper-Wide Heliar (Sony E-Mount)

Conclusion

Pros

  • Very solidly built lens with excellent mechanics
  • Very compact for the focal length
  • Exceptional width is unique in the photography world
  • Very sharp over most of the frame
  • Good flare control in most situations
  • Low distortion for a lens this wide
  • Excellent color and contrast
  • Reasonable price

Cons

  • Image edges and corners are a bit soft
  • High lateral chromatic aberration
  • Very high vignetting

The Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 Hyper-Wide Heliar is a truly unique lens. It’s the widest rectilinear lens made for any format in the history of photography. It also is pretty darn good optically, though definitely falls short of perfect.  There’s some softness at the edges, and the corners are softer still, but the overall resolution the lens produces is very good. It’s tack sharp in the center and the good sharpness extends over most of the frame.  It also shows fairly high chromatic aberration and very high vignetting, though both can be corrected to some degree in post-processing (with the addition of some noise in the case of vignetting).

Still, these drawbacks don’t spoil what is a truly magnificent lens. The 10mm f/5.6 has a wonderful drawing style, with great contrast and rich color, and it resists flare well in most circumstances.  But more important than the pure optical quality are the intangibles. Using this lens during the review period was the most fun I’ve had using a lens since I started this site 4.5 years ago.  It simply can do things no other lens can do.  I’ve been a fan of ultra-wide lenses for over a decade, and I didn’t even know I wanted wider than 14mm equivalent (my previous widest lens) until now.  It’s almost intoxicating to use this lens.  In less than two days of use, I knew this would be my next gear purchase, and I’ve already started saving for it. Voigtländer has created something special with the Hyper-Wide Heliar; It’s a gem.

Image Samples

Click on an image to enlarge.

RPAC at The Ohio State University - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
RPAC at The Ohio State University – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Statehouse Foyer - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
Statehouse Foyer – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Columbus Under the Bridge - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
Columbus Under the Bridge – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/16
McKinley Monument - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
McKinley Monument – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
University Hall - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
University Hall – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Alley Cone - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Alley Cone – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Sweeping Clouds over Columbus - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/16 (stack of 64 images with Smooth Reflections app)
Sweeping Clouds over Columbus – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/11 (stack of 64 images with Smooth Reflections app)
Hayden Run Falls - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/16
Hayden Run Falls – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/16
One way - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
One way – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Statehouse Staircase - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Statehouse Staircase – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Extremely Wide and Close - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
Extremely Wide and Close – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Columbus Lines - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
Columbus Lines – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/11
Ohio Stadium Reflected - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
Ohio Stadium Reflected – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Hayden Run - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/9
Hayden Run – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/9
McKinley Monument - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/
McKinley Monument – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/8
Columbus Fountain - Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/11 (stack of 32 exposures with Smooth Reflections app)
Columbus Fountain – Sony A7 II with Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 @ f/11 (stack of 32 exposures with Smooth Reflections app)

Pages: 1 2 3

Tags:

Comments

20 responses to “Review: Voigtländer 10mm f/5.6 Hyper-Wide Heliar (Sony E-Mount)”

  1. benji Avatar
    benji

    Nice shots

  2. Chris Avatar
    Chris

    Thanks for the review. I just joined you in the “saving up for this lens” club.

  3. Matt Avatar
    Matt

    A very informative review and a fascinating lens – I have the Sony 16-35, and find myself using 16mm a lot more than I ever expected, as you say that feels very wide in isolation.

    I think I might have to rent this, I’m not sure exactly what I’d use it for, but it’s a unique and lovely-looking piece of kit, which you can clearly take good photos with!

  4. Vladimir d'Ar Avatar

    Good Shots! Already want him a company to my FE 16-35/4!)

  5. […] read more of his thoughts on Admiring Light and say hi on Twitter. This article was originally published here and shared with permission. googletag.cmd.push(function() { […]

  6. Patrick Avatar
    Patrick

    The first and third images (“RPAC” and “Hayden Run Falls”) are really great. They show what’s possible with such a wide lens. I think I would struggle keeping the lines straight on architecture shots, however. Is the McKinley Monument shot cropped?

    1. Jordan Steele Avatar

      The second one is from close up, with verticals corrected in post. The first one, with the sun, is not cropped, and was taken level. The first image (RPAC) was cropped while keeping the camera level.

  7. Lisandra Avatar
    Lisandra

    Hey jordan, long time!!!! This lens is amazeballs to say the least. While it can be frustrating at times to shoot at such a wide view and keep it interesting while keeping the uninteresting out, it still remains a blast. Poeple also need to rent this thing. There simply no way to imagine or compare the angle of view to anything else. Even if you have the sigma 12-24 like i have the 10mm still is worlds different. Amazing as always

  8. Jay Mora Avatar
    Jay Mora

    You sir take great photos. It really makes reading the reviews worthwhile.

  9. Joel Cure Avatar

    Owned one for several days. My copy had extremely soft edges. I returned it.

    https://flic.kr/s/aHskGhVZsJ

    I will probably try another copy.

  10. Luis Castaneda Avatar

    I have been wondering about this lens for several months, but after finding your review and the magnificent examples, I am completely convinced to get it. I’ve had the incredible experience with the Voightländer 12mm for many years, but with the recent Leica cameras it vignettes very much ( although I don’t know if the recent versions of this lens the vignetting has been corrected). Thank you for the excellent review.

  11. Ramil Avatar
    Ramil

    He took pictures of this lens.
    The lens strongly pulls the shapes of objects from the center to the sides !!!
    Stretches the corners not only to the right and to the left but also to the top, down – and very much!
    It looks like Kosinas nakosyachil strongly not taking any measures to correct distortions.
    This lens will work correctly when the matrix is ??made semicircular, then the beam will pass the same distance in the center and at the edges of the frame.
    My opinion for filming in the room and in nature it is useless, once again convinced that the reviews over the hill are paid.
    If honestly it is not clear for what purpose this small piece of scrap metal?

  12. Marco Avatar
    Marco

    Great review and excellent shots! I have the same lens but the 12mm focal lenght, it’s the only lens I always have in my bag, it’s small, quite challenging in composition but extremely satisfying when you take a good picture. I’m eagerly waiting for the 65mm to arrive in Italy, I’m saving for that?

  13. Victor R. Avatar
    Victor R.

    Thank you, Jordan, for this review.

    I wonder if you’ve had any opportunities to use the 15mm F/4.5 Heliar for the e-mount? I’ve read good things about that lens on Phillip Reeve’s website, although it has also been criticized for quality control issues (sample-to-sample variations more prevalent than with the 10mm).

  14. Hamad Avatar

    Thank you Jordan.
    Highly detailed review. Thanks for providing such a great sample work along with it. After reading and seeing photos of your review i have decided to go for it as well. I used 12mm and was happy with it. then got the 15mm it was great too but after that they launched the 10mm was playing around with the idea of getting and now i am completely sold on it.

  15. […] Admiringlight??????????HELIAR-HYPER WIDE 10mm F5.6 Aspherical??????????????? […]

  16. Mark B Avatar
    Mark B

    Had a first-version Cosina / Voigtlander 12mm f/5.6 Hyper-Wide Heliar VM on a Leica M8 and Fuji X-E2. I never got used to the extreme vignetting and cyan corners of that lens on those cameras, so I sold it. Cosina / Voigtlander’s (first version) 15mm f/4.5 Ultra-Wide Heliar was easier to use, but still vignetted pretty badly. So I sold that lens, too.

    Now I’m using Leica’s 16-18-21mm f/4 Tri-Elmar-M ASPH full-frame on Leica M10 (superlative image quality, but co$tly). When I need to go really wide, I’ll use Sigma’s 14mm f/1.8 Art on an EOS 5D mk IV, but shooting real estate for clients I’ll use an EF 17mm f/4L TS-E or first-version EF 24mm f/3.5L TS-E. All of them are relatively distortionless compared to the first version EF 16-35mm f/2.8L I used to use for real estate and Chacoan Anasazi ruins.

    The Sigma 14mm is also excellent for night sky / starfield shots – very little coma or distortion of any kind, very sharp to the corners.

    I don’t really have a use for a 10mm lens, but admit to a technical fascination with wider/longer/faster optics. Thank you for showing more possibilities for ultra-wide composition, particularly the Ohio Statehouse Rotunda.

    (More of my work at http://www.activelightphotography.com)

  17. Ash C Avatar
    Ash C

    Thank you for hosting this really informative and useful website.
    I love reading your reviews – always so balanced and fair.
    I have a dilema and was hoping you can help
    I have a sony Aiii and I want to buy an ultra wide angle lens.
    My experience till now have been with 24mm at the widest
    I am looking at the Voigtlander 10mm with 5.6 and the 15mm with 4. The 15mm in my mind is the safe choice with the relative ease of composing a pic but the possibility of a 10mm excites me too. My questions are –
    1. Is it advisable to buy the 10mm and get used to it and during that time also use it if needed in APSC format (A7iii allows you to) when the effective focal length will be 15mm. In that case could I enjoy best of both worlds?
    2. How much of difference will the 5.6 stop of 10mm be a hindrance compared to the 4 of 15mm in the verstality of the lenses to take good images
    Thank you for your help
    Best wishes

  18. […] options as well.  Among those unique lenses are their extreme wide-angle lenses, such as the 10mm f/5.6, which I reviewed two years ago, and today’s reviewed lens, the 12mm f/5.6 Ultra Wide Heliar […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search


Categories


Recent Posts


  1. Great review. I shoot Nikon and may try an old Nikon D200 and see how it compares with the new…

  2. Your article brings back some very fond memories. I had exact setup you describe. The 15-85 lens on the 30D…